The Violin Concerto is the most accurate reflection
of the lyrical side of Beethoven's musical personality.
There is no trace of tragic intensity, inner
struggle, suffering or overwhelming passion
anywhere in the forty-five minute long piece:
it is governed by a superior harmony and an
equilibrium of scale which make the work one
of the highpoints in the history of music.
"The melody pours forth in a divinely peaceful
form.. permeated with the pure harmony of D
major" (Riezler), with a series of surprises,
typical of Beethoven, which leave the sweetness
of the music untouched. His decision to open
the piece with four beats on the timpani is
quite original; the violins come in on the tenth
beat on an unexpected note (D sharp) which is
resolved in a similarly unusual manner (ending
on C sharp instead of E); the transitional motif,
played fortissimo over the harmony in B flat,
hints at the unpredictable, powerful side of
Beethoven's personality.
It is difficult to understand why Beethoven's
Violin Concerto did not immediately receive
the universal renown it enjoys today. Reports
of the first ever performance tell us that it
met with the approval of the public (not surprising,
since it was played by the artistic director
of the theatre, a highly regarded musician)
but was not well received by music critics:
the fact that the piece had been rehearsed sketchily
and in very little time would have no doubt
influenced the audience. Probably as a result,
the concert was not performed again for many
years, until after Beethoven's death.
The pianist and publisher Muzio Clementi commissioned
Beethoven to write a version of the concerto
with a solo for piano. Beethoven modified the
solo score (the orchestral part remained the
same) and performed the new version himself,
but the concerto was badly received and fell
into oblivion. While it was written with a deep
understanding and knowledge of the instrument,
the piano version undermines the original idea
which was "created" for the violin; it is performed
rarely today, mostly out of curiosity.
Despite this Beethoven did not abandon the
piece: he went on to dedicate it to his childhood
friend Stephan von Breuning to whom he was extremely
close; the version for piano is dedicated to
Julie von Vering, "Steffen's" wife. The Breuning
family was a great solace to Beethoven on the
death of his mother (1786) and the bonds of
friendship between the two men lasted a lifetime.
Breuning died of a liver complaint three months
after Beethoven's death. Breuning's son Gerhard
wrote a biography which contains important first
hand information on the composer.
It was the violinist Joseph Joachim, friend
of Brahms (to whom his violin concerto is dedicated),
who brought the concert to light in 1844; his
performances of the piece were conducted by
Mendelsshon and Schumann on various occasions.
Opinions of the concerto remain divided even
today: many critics point to a lack of balance
between the movements, the excessive uniformity
of the violin score and the over-conventional
nature of the third movement; musicians are
unanimous in their opinion of it as one of the
highpoints in the history of music and the concerto
remains the most performed and recorded in the
violin repertoire.
|